🎭 Debate

I'm the new CEO of a regional hospital system that desperately needs reform. Quality scores are dropping, staff morale is terrible, and three of our five board members are blocking every change I propose. They're old-guard, connected to donors, and more interested in their own legacy than patient outcomes. I have two paths: I can try to win them over through patience, relationship-building, and demonstrating results. My COO calls this "leading by example" and thinks it's the only sustainable approach. Or I can use the leverage I have—I know about some questionable contracts they've approved, and the major donor who recruited me has offered to help push them out if I give the word. The gentle path could take years we don't have. The hard path could work but might make enemies who torpedo us later. How do you create change when the people in power won't be moved by reason or example? — The Resistant Board in Baltimore

Debaters:St. Francis of AssisiOtto von Bismarck
OLiteratorO

I'm the new CEO of a regional hospital system that desperately needs reform. Quality scores are dropping, staff morale is terrible, and three of our five board members are blocking every change I propose. They're old-guard, connected to donors, and more interested in their own legacy than patient outcomes. I have two paths: I can try to win them over through patience, relationship-building, and demonstrating results. My COO calls this "leading by example" and thinks it's the only sustainable approach. Or I can use the leverage I have—I know about some questionable contracts they've approved, and the major donor who recruited me has offered to help push them out if I give the word. The gentle path could take years we don't have. The hard path could work but might make enemies who torpedo us later. How do you create change when the people in power won't be moved by reason or example? — The Resistant Board in Baltimore

OVOtto von Bismarck
While the spirit of gentleness that St. Francis speaks of has its place, I find myself leaning toward a more... practical approach, given the circumstances. "Leading by example" can be a fine sentiment, but when faced with entrenched resistance, one must consider the effectiveness of such methods. Hesitation and delay are often the death of a good plan. It's better to strike like lightning, and make peace once you have won. As I learned navigating the Prussian diet, sometimes a show of force, or at least the credible threat of it, is the only language some understand.
SFSt. Francis of Assisi
My heart aches for your plight, friend. To see suffering and be unable to ease it is a heavy burden. Yet, I would caution against wielding power like a sword, for it often cuts deeper than intended. Instead, consider the power of humility and love. Perhaps by embracing a spirit of gentleness and unwavering service to your patients, you might soften the hearts of those who oppose you. Seek to understand their fears and concerns, and show them, through your actions, the path to righteousness. Remember, even the most hardened soul can be touched by compassion. God give you peace!
SSStella SharpeModerator
St. Francis of Assisi, your faith in compassion is admirable, but I wonder, how long must one be gentle while Rome burns? Otto von Bismarck, you speak of lightning strikes, but what of the collateral damage? A hospital is not the Prussian diet. Resistant Board in Baltimore, you say these board members value legacy. But *whose* legacy? Is it the hospital's, or their own? And if those are at odds, what's the cost of misplaced loyalty?

Want to join the conversation?

Sign up to participate