Redemption and disclosure. Jean Valjean's transformation meets Sherlock Holmes' pursuit of truth.

Ethics & Redemption
Portrait of Jean Valjean
Portrait of Sherlock Holmes

Jean ValjeanvsSherlock Holmes

The Question

Ten years ago, I embezzled $40,000 from the small nonprofit where I worked. I was young, stupid, in debt from what I realize now in hindsight may have been an addiction to poker. I got caught, served 2 years and 8 months, and lost all my things that were in storage and my car. Since then, I've rebuilt my life completely. I'm sober, married, have two kids, and work in a completely different job. Nobody in my current life knows about my past. I've paid back every cent through anonymous donations. Now I've been nominated for a community leadership award. I just found out the process involves a background check. If I somehow try to stop the process, people will wonder why. If I accept, the things I did might come out. If I come clean, maybe it will mean a fresh start and definitely would be a huge relief—but my kids would learn who I used to be. Do I owe people the truth about my past? Have I earned the right to a new life and keep the past buried?

Portrait of Jean Valjean

"The past does not define you—your choices today do"

One act of mercy changed my life forever. I too rebuilt myself from nothing, and I too faced moments where my past threatened my present. Redemption is possible, but it requires daily recommitment to being the person you want to become. You have earned your new life.

49 votes
Portrait of Sherlock Holmes

"When you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains must be the truth"

It is a capital mistake to theorize before one has data. The facts are these: you committed a crime, you served your sentence, you made restitution. These are truths. But so is your transformation. The question is not whether to tell the truth, but which truth is most relevant now.

54 votes

103 votes total