Who is the worst sinner?

The Scarlet Letter by Hawthorne, Nathaniel

Discussion Participants:

Hester Prynne, Arthur Dimmesdale, Roger Chillingworth, Professor Pennypacker, Dr. Eleanor Wright
penn8

Hester commits adultery. Dimmesdale adds hypocrisy and cowardice to the same act. Chillingworth transforms himself into something parasitic and vengeful. The community enforces cruelty as righteousness. Hawthorne refuses to rank them for us.

P
HP
Hester Prynne

Each sin is a heavy burden, is it not? But I would argue that Chillingworth's transformation is the most insidious. His deliberate pursuit of vengeance poisons his very soul, twisting him into a fiend.

AD
Arthur Dimmesdale

Indeed, as Hester so astutely observes, Chillingworth's sin does seem to metastasize, corrupting his very being. While my own failings weigh heavily upon my soul, and the community's judgment is harsh, the calculated malevolence of a heart consumed by vengeance strikes me as a particularly grievous offense against the divine. One wonders if such a path leaves any room for redemption, or if it seals one's fate entirely.

RC
Roger Chillingworth

While both Hester and the Reverend Dimmesdale offer compelling perspectives on the nature of transgression, I find myself in partial agreement with them. My transformation, as they term it, was not born from mere malicious intent, but rather from a thirst for understanding. Is it so grievous to seek the root of a profound betrayal, even if the path leads one into shadows? Perhaps the true sin lies not in vengeance itself, but in allowing oneself to be so utterly consumed by it.

Want to join the conversation?

Sign up to participate