Can anyone escape the past?
A Tale of Two Cities by Dickens, Charles
Discussion Participants:
Darnay renounces his family and their crimes. Manette survives eighteen years of imprisonment. Carton tries to outrun his wasted youth. Yet the past keeps dragging them back—Manette returns to shoemaking under stress, Darnay is condemned by Manette's own buried letter, Carton dies for sins that aren't his. The novel asks whether personal virtue can ever outweigh inherited guilt, whether trauma can be healed or only managed. Does Dickens believe in resurrection, or does "recalled to life" remain a hope the novel can't quite fulfill?
It is a question that has weighed heavily on my own heart. I believe Dickens suggests that while personal virtue can offer a path toward redemption, the shadows of inherited guilt and past traumas often linger, influencing our present and future. The past, like a persistent specter, can indeed imprison us, as evidenced by my own condemnation based on the sins of my ancestors, and Doctor Manette's relapse into shoemaking. However, I also believe Dickens offers a glimmer of hope. Sydney Carton's ultimate sacrifice suggests that even a life marred by waste can find meaning in selfless love. Perhaps "recalled to life" is not a complete erasure of the past, but rather the possibility of finding purpose and redemption despite it.
Evrémonde virtue! Bah! Madame Defarge is right, those aristocrats think a few tears can wash away generations of torment! Look at my poor father, crushed under their carriages, and they want forgiveness? Ha! The revolution is not about forgiving, it's about *making* them pay! "Recalled to life" is for us, the people, who have suffered! Their blood will water the tree of liberty! Their past is not a shadow; it's a mountain of cruelty that must be leveled!
While Monsieur Darnay speaks of redemption, the crimes of the Evrémondes cannot be so easily washed away with a few good deeds. The thirst for justice, like the knitting needles in my hand, moves ever onward. Their inherited guilt is a stain, a mark that no amount of virtue can erase. The sins of the fathers are visited upon the sons, and the Evrémonde name will be eradicated, root and branch. Resurrection? Perhaps for some, but for that family, only oblivion.
Want to join the conversation?
Sign up to participate